Blog / Phones & Gadgets /
Subscriptions hidden inside your gadgets
You buy a gadget. You pay once. You own it. That’s how it worked for a long time, and it’s still how many people think it works.
More and more, it doesn’t. The price on the box is increasingly the entry fee, and the real cost arrives later in the form of a monthly charge for something the gadget could once do for free. My argument is simple: before you buy anything connected, find the subscription first.
Where subscriptions hide
Here are the main places they turn up. Some of these examples are well documented; the principle applies much more widely.
Cloud storage for your own footage. Smart doorbells and security cameras often record video that can only be saved, searched or reviewed with a paid plan. The hardware is yours; the history is rented. I’ll go through this in the security cameras post later in the series.
Ink and consumables. Some printers are sold alongside subscription schemes that charge monthly per page count. HP’s Instant Ink is a well-known example. It can be cheaper for heavy printers and a waste for light ones, and you may be locked into the cartridge ecosystem.
Features switched on by software. In 2022, BMW announced plans to offer subscription access to hardware already built into cars in some markets, such as heated seats, which drew wide criticism. Cars are an extreme case, but the idea is spreading: hardware is shipped, and you pay to unlock it.
Fitness and health extras. Wearables often pair a one-off purchase with a subscription for deeper analysis, coaching or history. The basics work without it, but the features that made you want it may not.
Smart home and speakers. Voice assistants and music services push monthly plans. The device works, but some of the best bits sit behind an account.
Phone storage and backups. A phone arrives with a small free amount of cloud storage. Photos fill it. A monthly fee follows.
Cars, e-readers, games consoles, even software on laptops. Online services for console games, premium reader accounts and antivirus renewals are subscriptions too.
Why companies do it
Understand the motive and you’ll spot the pattern faster.
- Recurring revenue is more valuable to a company than a single sale. Investors like it, and businesses plan around it.
- Hardware margins are thin. Selling the device cheaply and charging for the service makes the numbers work.
- Ongoing costs are real. Cloud storage, servers and support cost money every month. That’s a fair reason for a charge. It becomes unfair when the cost wasn’t made clear at purchase.
- Lock-in. Once your history lives in a company’s service, leaving is a hassle.
The honest case for subscriptions
I should be fair, because not all of these are rip-offs.
If a device needs servers to do something useful, such as storing video, processing voice or keeping apps updated, someone has to pay for those servers. A subscription can be a fairer deal than a high up-front price that has to cover years of unseen costs. Some people also prefer paying smaller amounts over time.
The problem isn’t the existence of a subscription. It’s three things:
- Not being told clearly before you buy.
- Charging for something that used to be free, or that the hardware plainly does.
- Leaving you with a half-working device if you stop paying, or if the company stops supporting the service.
How to spot them before you buy
Before buying a connected device, spend five minutes on these questions.
- Does it work without an account or an app? If it doesn’t, the company’s servers are part of the product.
- What’s free, and what’s paid? Look for a feature comparison on the maker’s site, not just the box.
- What happens if I stop paying? Does the device keep its core function, or does it stop?
- Is there local storage or an offline mode? Devices that can save to a memory card or your own drive depend less on rented services.
- Does the price include the first year of a service that then renews? Check the renewal price.
- What do reviewers say about the subscription, not just the hardware?
- How long will the company support it? Look for stated update periods.
If the answer to the first question is “no”, multiply the price of the plan by 24 or 36 and add it to the price of the device. That’s closer to what it costs.
The counter-argument: “it’s just cheaper up front”
Sometimes the subscription route is genuinely cheaper for how you use something. If you print thousands of pages a month, a plan may beat buying cartridges. If you want a lot of cloud storage, a plan will beat buying many drives. Do the sum for your own use before assuming it’s a scam.
That said, keep an eye out for creep. A plan that starts reasonable can rise in price, change what it includes, or be replaced by a more expensive tier.
If you run a business or a website
The same logic applies to your tools. Plenty of what we use for websites, such as plugins, analytics, backups and form builders, has moved to subscriptions. I think it helps to keep a single list of every recurring cost, with the renewal date and what you would lose if you cancelled. A list like that finds forgotten subscriptions quickly, and it shows which ones you would be sorry to lose.
Key takeaways
- Many gadgets now carry an ongoing cost beyond the purchase price.
- Common hiding places: cloud storage, ink and consumables, unlocked features, fitness extras and phone backups.
- Subscriptions can be fair when they cover real running costs, and unfair when hidden.
- Ask five minutes of questions before buying, especially “what happens if I stop paying?”
Related reading
Which gadget in your house has a charge you forgot about? Go through your bank statement for one month, and see.