Blog / Tech, New & Old /

Vinyl and cassette comebacks

Streaming gives you more or less every song ever released for the price of a monthly subscription. And yet record shops are busy, new turntables keep appearing, and cassette tapes, which looked finished by the early 2000s, are back on shelves.

That’s not a contradiction. People aren’t buying vinyl and tapes because they sound better than a streaming file or because they’re cheaper. They’re buying something streaming can’t give: an object, a ritual and a sense of ownership.

The numbers, as far as I’m sure of them

In 2020, vinyl record sales in the United States overtook CD sales by revenue for the first time since the 1980s, according to the recording industry’s trade body, the RIAA. Vinyl has continued to sell strongly since. Cassettes started from a far smaller base, but sales rose noticeably through the 2010s. I won’t quote exact current figures, since they move every year; the trade bodies in your country publish up-to-date ones.

A short history

Vinyl. The long-playing record arrived in the late 1940s and ruled home listening for decades. The 12-inch LP spins at 33⅓ revolutions per minute, with a smaller 7-inch single at 45. A needle (the stylus) rides the groove, and its tiny movements are converted into an electrical signal and then into sound.

Cassette. Philips introduced the compact cassette in 1963, a small plastic case of magnetic tape on two spools. It was portable and, importantly, recordable. Sony’s Walkman, launched in 1979, put music in your pocket and changed how people listened. Cassettes ruled mixtapes, car stereos and, in many countries, local music markets, before CDs and then MP3s took over.

Why the comeback

It’s an object

A record sleeve is big enough to show artwork properly. A cassette case is small and collectable. You can hold them, lend them and put them on a shelf. In a world where music is invisible, an object counts for something.

It slows you down

You pick a record, lower the needle, and listen to a whole side. Flipping it over is part of the experience. People who describe themselves as skipping songs constantly on streaming say vinyl makes them hear albums as albums.

It supports artists in a different way

Fans often buy merchandise to support artists they like, and a record or tape is a form of that. Small labels and independent artists can press limited runs and sell them directly, which is an appealing model for both sides.

Nostalgia, including borrowed nostalgia

Some buyers grew up with these formats. Plenty didn’t, and find them interesting for that exact reason. Retro style travels well on social media, which feeds the cycle.

Sound, with a caveat

Many people prefer how vinyl sounds, describing it as warmer. Whether it’s more accurate is another matter: digital formats can capture a wider, cleaner range than vinyl or tape, and records are often mastered differently for the format. Surface noise, wear and imperfect equipment affect what you hear. My honest view is that preference is real and personal, but “better” is not a safe claim. Tape has its hiss; vinyl has its crackle; some people love both.

What each format asks of you

Vinyl Cassette
Equipment Turntable, amp or powered speakers, a phono stage (built in or separate) Tape player or deck
Care Keep clean, flat, away from heat; stylus wears Keep away from heat and magnets; tape can stretch or tangle
Portability Low Good
Recording No Yes, on blank tapes
Cost to start Moderate, and it adds up Often low if you find an old player

If you want to try vinyl

  1. Check the turntable and what it connects to. Some turntables have a built-in preamp (phono stage) so they can plug into ordinary powered speakers. Others need a separate preamp or an amplifier with a phono input. Plugging a turntable without a phono stage into the wrong input gives you very quiet, tinny sound.
  2. Avoid the cheapest all-in-one players if you value your records. Poor tonearms and heavy tracking forces can wear grooves faster. A decent entry-level turntable from a known audio brand is a safer buy.
  3. Start with used records. Check the condition of the vinyl, not just the sleeve. Look for scratches under a light.
  4. Look after it. A soft brush, storing records upright in inner sleeves, and no stacking.

If you want to try cassettes

Old players can be unreliable. Belts perish, heads wear out, and tape can be eaten by a tired mechanism. Test before you buy, or choose a refurbished unit. New blank and pre-recorded tapes are being made again. Remember that a tape you value shouldn’t be left in a hot car.

The practical web angle

The revival says something for anyone selling online. Physical products with a story sell next to free digital alternatives, as long as the physical thing offers something extra: art, ritual, scarcity or connection. Independent musicians use their own websites and online shops to sell these directly, and small online shops can do well with niche products and honest descriptions. If you sell physical goods, clear photos, accurate condition notes and good packaging do more than clever copy.

For more on how old formats shaped what came next, the iPod’s click wheel and why it felt magic picks up the story.

Key takeaways

  • Vinyl and cassettes are selling for the experience and the object, not for better sound.
  • Vinyl needs a turntable, a phono stage and care; cassettes are cheaper but fragile.
  • Preference for analogue sound is real; “better” is debatable.
  • For sellers, a physical product needs a reason to exist beside a free stream.

FAQ

Is vinyl better than streaming?

Not in measurable accuracy. Many people prefer the experience and the sound character, which is a valid choice.

Do I need an expensive setup?

No. A modest turntable with a decent cartridge and powered speakers is enough to start.

Can I digitise my old tapes?

Yes, with a working player and an audio interface, and you can record into free software. Do it before the tapes deteriorate further.

If you could bring back one format for a month, would it be a record, a tape or something else?