Blog / Tech, New & Old /
MP3 players before the iPod
The iPod is often remembered as the first MP3 player. It wasn’t even close. When Apple launched it in October 2001, small digital music players had been on sale for three years, and several of them were quite clever. They just weren’t easy.
This is the story of those earlier machines: what they did, why most people ignored them, and what the iPod changed.
First, what an MP3 is
MP3 is a way of shrinking audio files. It throws away sounds that most ears are unlikely to notice, which cuts the size of a song to roughly a tenth of its CD version. That’s what made digital music practical. A song became a file small enough to store on a computer and to send over the slow internet connections of the late 1990s.
The format came from research in Germany, with the Fraunhofer Institute playing a major role, and became part of the MPEG audio standard in the early 1990s. Programs like Winamp (1997) made playing MP3s on a PC easy, and Napster (1999) made finding them even easier, at least until the legal trouble started.
Once music was a file, the next question was obvious: can I carry it?
The early players
MPMan (1998)
The MPMan F10, made by the South Korean company Saehan, is often called the first commercial MP3 player. It was small, with a tiny display, and held only a few songs’ worth of memory by modern standards, loaded from a PC over a parallel port.
Diamond Rio PMP300 (1998)
The Rio, from Diamond Multimedia, became the best-known early player in the United States. It had about 32 megabytes of flash memory, roughly enough for a dozen songs at normal quality, and ran on a single AA battery. It also attracted a lawsuit: the recording industry’s trade body tried to block it, arguing that it encouraged piracy. A court ruled in the Rio’s favour in 1999, which opened the way for portable players to be sold legally.
Creative Nomad and Archos Jukebox (2000)
Memory was the problem. Flash was expensive, so a different approach came: put a hard drive inside. The Archos Jukebox 6000, from 2000, and Creative’s Nomad Jukebox could store hundreds of songs. They were bulky, with a heavy battery appetite, and the interface felt like a computer’s. But the idea of a library in your pocket was right.
Others
Companies such as iRiver, Samsung and Sony also made players, with varying quality. Many used flash memory and cheap chips. Sony in particular had a complicated approach to music formats and copy protection, which made its early players awkward.
What they did well
- They proved the idea. People wanted portable digital music.
- Flash players had no moving parts, so they didn’t skip when you jogged.
- Hard-drive players held huge libraries compared with a CD player.
- They were compatible with the open MP3 format, so you could use files from anywhere.
Why most people didn’t care
The software was painful
Putting music on a player meant clunky transfer programs, driver installs and odd file-management quirks. Each manufacturer had its own. You needed to be patient with computers.
The interfaces were bad
Navigating a thousand songs with tiny buttons and a two-line screen was slow. Finding the track you wanted could take longer than the song itself.
The sizes were wrong
Flash players were small and held few songs. Hard-drive players held many but were chunky. Neither felt like the right trade-off.
Transfer was slow
Many used USB 1.1, which moved files at a snail’s pace. Filling a player could take a long time.
The legal picture was murky
Mainstream, legal ways to buy digital music were thin on the ground. For most people, an MP3 meant downloading something from a questionable source.
What the iPod changed
Apple didn’t invent the idea. It took a collection of awkward parts and made them work together.
- A small hard drive. The first iPod had a 5 GB drive, which Apple described as “1,000 songs in your pocket”. That gave capacity without the Jukebox’s bulk.
- FireWire. Fast transfer for the time, which meant a full library moved quickly.
- The scroll wheel. A way to move through long lists quickly. I wrote about this detail in the iPod’s click wheel and why it felt magic.
- iTunes. Software that organised the library and synced it automatically, so you hardly noticed the transfer step.
- Design. A clean, simple object that people wanted to be seen with.
Later came the iTunes Store (2003), which finally made buying digital music easy and legal for many people. The lesson stands out: the technology was there before, but the experience wasn’t. For more on that, what the iPod can teach about simple products is the companion read.
What it still teaches
- First isn’t the same as best. Many technologies are launched by one company and perfected by another.
- Software and ease beat specs. A better experience matters more than a bigger number.
- Legal and business systems matter. A device needs somewhere to get content from.
- Constraints shape design. Memory cost drove early compromises; cheaper storage solved them.
If you build digital products, it’s worth asking which of those four your idea depends on, and which are still missing.
Key takeaways
- MP3 players existed from 1998, years before the iPod.
- Early players were hampered by small memory, clumsy software and poor interfaces.
- Hard-drive players solved capacity but were bulky.
- The iPod combined capacity, speed, interface, software and design.
FAQ
Was the iPod the first MP3 player?
No. The MPMan and Rio were on sale in 1998, and several others followed before the iPod in 2001.
Could the iPod play MP3s?
Yes. It supported MP3 and other formats, including Apple’s AAC.
Why did the early players need so much patience?
Slow transfer, bad software and tiny displays all got in the way.
Related reading
Which gadget did you first use that finally made digital music make sense to you?