Blog / How the internet works /

CAPTCHAs and the alternatives

You are trying to book something, and a grid appears: “Select all squares with traffic lights.” You click, it shows a new grid, and you wonder if the bus counts. Somewhere a form owner thought this was a good trade. For them it stops spam. For you it costs patience.

CAPTCHA stands for “Completely Automated Public Turing test to tell Computers and Humans Apart”. It is a challenge meant to be easy for people and hard for bots. If you run a site with forms, comments or logins, you will have to decide whether to use one, and which.

Why sites use them

Forms attract bots. A contact form, a comment box, a registration page or a login screen will be found and abused if they are open. The result is junk in your inbox, fake accounts and, with logins, attempts to guess passwords. I looked at the form-plugin side of this in WordPress form plugins: speed and spam.

The main options

Google reCAPTCHA

The best known. Two versions are common.

  • v2 shows the “I’m not a robot” checkbox, and sometimes an image puzzle.
  • v3 works invisibly in the background, scoring each visitor on how human they seem, and you decide what to do with a low score.

Good: free, effective, familiar. Less good: it loads Google scripts, which affects speed and privacy, and it raises GDPR and cookie-consent questions in Europe. Image puzzles are also hard for people with visual or motor impairments.

hCaptcha

Similar in style to reCAPTCHA but run by a different company with a privacy-forward pitch. It is often chosen by people who want to avoid Google. It still asks users to solve puzzles, so the annoyance is similar.

Cloudflare Turnstile

Launched in 2022 as a “no puzzle” alternative. It runs a series of small checks in the browser and usually passes real users without any interaction. It is free, and it works even if your site does not use Cloudflare for anything else. For many small sites it is the easiest improvement.

Honeypots

A hidden form field that humans never see but bots fill in. If it comes back with something in it, the submission is rejected. It costs the visitor nothing and works against simple bots. Some bots are smart enough to skip hidden fields, so it is better as one layer than as the only defence.

Time checks

A form submitted in less than two seconds was probably not typed by a person. Measuring the time between page load and submit is another invisible layer.

Akismet and similar filters

Spam filters that examine the content after submission, using patterns learned from many sites. Akismet is widely used for WordPress comments and some form plugins. It catches spam that bots send even after they pass the first test.

Email confirmation and rate limiting

For sign-ups, require a confirmed email address. For logins, limit attempts per IP. Neither bothers an honest user much.

Two-factor authentication

For login protection, two-factor beats a CAPTCHA. Bots that guess passwords never get past the second step. It is the stronger lock for anything with an admin area.

The real cost of CAPTCHAs

It is easy to focus on spam and forget what the challenge costs.

  • Lost conversions. Every extra step loses some people. For a checkout or lead form, that is real money.
  • Accessibility. Puzzles that depend on sight, hearing or fine mouse control shut out some users. Audio alternatives are often poor. This is one of the clearest places where accessibility and business interest meet, a theme I covered in accessibility and SEO: where they overlap.
  • Speed. Third-party scripts add weight to every page that includes them.
  • Privacy. Some services collect behavioural data to decide who is human.
  • Bots are getting better. Modern AI can solve many image puzzles. The arms race is real, which is why invisible, behaviour-based checks are replacing puzzles.

How to choose

Start light and add only if you need to.

  1. Spam on a contact form? Honeypot plus a time check, plus Akismet if available. Add Turnstile or reCAPTCHA v3 if that is not enough.
  2. Comments? Moderation, Akismet and a honeypot. A CAPTCHA is rarely the first thing needed.
  3. Login pages? Limit attempts, add two-factor authentication, and use Turnstile if attacks continue.
  4. Shop sign-ups and checkout? Be very careful: friction here costs sales. Prefer invisible checks and fraud tools.
  5. High-risk, high-volume forms? A stronger invisible check, plus a firewall rule. See firewalls explained for site owners.

Implementation tips

  • Load the script only where needed. Do not add reCAPTCHA to every page of the site just because one page has a form. Many plugins load it everywhere by default.
  • Test as a real visitor, on mobile too, and with your own consent banner in place.
  • Keep a fallback. If a service goes down or blocks a legitimate user, give them a way to contact you.
  • Watch your numbers. If form submissions drop after adding a CAPTCHA, that is a signal.
  • Mention the service in your privacy policy if it processes visitor data.

Key takeaways

  • A CAPTCHA is one tool for stopping bots, and a costly one for real users.
  • Invisible checks such as Turnstile, honeypots and time checks add little friction.
  • Puzzle CAPTCHAs hurt accessibility and conversion.
  • Layer simple defences first, and add stronger ones only when spam persists.
  • Test forms as a visitor after any change.

FAQ

Is reCAPTCHA v3 better than v2?

It is less annoying for visitors because it usually shows nothing, but it needs thresholds tuned and still loads Google scripts. Whether it is “better” depends on your priorities.

Will a honeypot stop all spam?

No. It stops lazy bots. Treat it as a first filter.

Do I need a CAPTCHA on a small brochure site?

Often not. Try a honeypot and a spam filter first and see how much gets through.

Look at the last ten messages in your contact form’s inbox. If most are junk, you have your answer on whether to add anything. If most are real, leave the form alone.