Blog / Shopify & e-commerce /

How to use competitor research without copying their catalogue

A competitor has a tidy catalogue, and a few of their pages rank for searches you’d love to win. The temptation is to copy the structure and reword the descriptions. Please don’t. You’d inherit their assumptions along with their layout.

Competitor research earns its keep when it shows you customer questions, category conventions or gaps you can fill with your own verified information. That’s all.

Observe without cloning

Note what the competitor makes easy to compare, which attributes appear in filters and how pages guide the choice. Keep an observation separate from a conclusion about why it performs. Search results don’t show the business context behind a ranking. When I look at a competitor’s category page, I write down what I see first and only then ask why.

Bring the findings back to your catalogue

Check which customer needs overlap and where your range is different. Use product records, support input and search evidence to decide whether a gap matters. Don’t reproduce unsupported claims, proprietary descriptions or someone else’s distinctive presentation. Build your own explanation from facts you can verify. I don’t trust a “me too” page to win anything.

Choose a testable improvement

A better filter, a clearer compatibility note or a more useful collection may be worth testing. Track what changed and review the result sensibly.

A common mistake is treating the research as a to-do list. It isn’t. It’s a set of questions. “They have a compatibility filter” becomes “do our customers need one, and is our data clean enough to power it?” That second version is the useful one.

Another is researching only the biggest rivals. Smaller specialists often explain a product better, because they have to.

Keep your own voice, too. A competitor’s description may be clumsy or too technical. If your customers prefer plainer language, write that. The point of the research is to understand the shopper better, not to sound like someone else.

Make the review reusable

Write down the decision the research needs to support, then the evidence that could change it. Otherwise “competitor analysis” becomes a vague request to match everything they do.

Take one competitor page and trace what it offers the customer from first screen to buying decision. Note where your own page differs in wording, data or layout. Ask the merchandiser for a normal case and an exception. A process that only works for the simplest category will break on the odd ones.

If the evidence is thin, pick a small validation step and say what its limits are. A competitor’s page ranking tells you little about why.

Keep a record of what you changed because of the research and what the page said before. That lets you tell later whether the idea came from evidence or fashion.

Name who approves claims and who checks the live page. Make exceptions visible and scoped, so one borrowed idea doesn’t become a rule for the catalogue.

Finally, remember that your catalogue has strengths a rival can’t copy: your support answers, your warranty terms, your own product photos. Research should point you at those, not away from them.

Take a concrete case. Say a rival’s laptop category page has a filter for screen size and another for processor generation. That tells you shoppers expect to compare on those two attributes. It does not tell you your own product data holds clean values for them. Check that first, because a filter built on messy data is worse than no filter.

Then look at the gaps in their page, too. If every competitor skips warranty detail and your customers keep asking about it, that is a gap you can fill honestly.

Talk to the people who answer customers. Support and sales staff hear the questions competitors’ pages never show: “Will this fit my model?”, “Is the warranty local?”. Those questions are better research than another crawl.

Keep a simple record of what you borrowed as an idea and what you checked yourself. If a competitor lists compatibility in a filter, the idea is fair game. The data behind it must come from your own product records.

Be sceptical of the “they rank, so they must be right” argument. A competitor may rank for reasons that have nothing to do with the page, such as brand strength or links. Copy the page and you copy none of that.

Last, run the smallest test that could prove you wrong. One improved collection page is a better experiment than rebuilding the whole category tree on a hunch.

Revisit the research when the range or the competitor’s pages change. Which competitor observation points to a customer need your own catalogue can answer differently?