Blog / Phones & Gadgets /

Phone backups: iCloud vs Google One vs your computer

Phones get lost, dropped, stolen and dunked. Then comes the question nobody wants to answer at that moment: “When did I last back this up?”

A backup is boring until the day it is the only thing that matters. The good news is that setting one up takes about ten minutes. The harder part is choosing where it goes. Here is the short answer first, then the details.

The short answer

  • iPhone user who wants it to just happen: iCloud backup, switched on, with enough storage.
  • Android user: Google’s backup (managed through Google One storage), plus your phone maker’s tool if it has one.
  • Want control, privacy or no monthly fee: back up to your computer, regularly.
  • Best option for most people: cloud plus an occasional copy of photos somewhere else.

At a glance

iCloud Google One / Google backup Your computer
Works on iPhone and iPad Android iPhone or Android
Free storage 5GB 15GB, shared with Gmail and Drive As much as your disk
Automatic Yes, on Wi-Fi and charging Yes No, you do it
Needs internet Yes Yes No
Monthly cost Paid tiers after the free space Paid tiers after the free space None
Restore New phone setup New phone setup Cable, software

iCloud backup

Apple gives 5GB free. It stores much of your device settings, app data, photos (if you are not already using iCloud Photos) and messages. When you set up a new iPhone, you sign in and restore.

Strengths: it is automatic, and restoring is simple. It works without a computer.

Weaknesses: 5GB is tiny. Photos and videos fill it fast, so most people pay for more. It also depends on Wi-Fi, a charged phone and enough bandwidth, which is a real problem on slow or expensive connections.

Google One and Android backup

Android phones back up certain data to your Google account: contacts, calendar, some settings, app data and, with Google Photos, your pictures. You get 15GB free, shared with Gmail, Google Drive and Photos. Google One is the paid plan that adds storage.

Strengths: deeply built into Android, easy for contacts and photos, and shared across devices.

Weaknesses: the 15GB shared pool fills up, and exactly what is backed up varies by phone and Android version. Samsung and other makers have their own backup tools too, which can confuse things.

Backing up to a computer

You connect the phone to a Mac or PC and copy it to your disk. On Apple devices, this is done through Finder (on recent macOS) or iTunes (on Windows). On Android, you can copy files and photos over USB or use the maker’s desktop tool.

Strengths: no monthly fee, no internet needed, you keep control and can encrypt it. An encrypted iPhone backup also keeps things like saved passwords and health data, which cloud backups handle differently.

Weaknesses: you have to remember. And if the computer dies or is stolen along with the phone, so does your backup. Android computer backups usually miss app data.

What backups miss

Check these, because people assume they are covered.

  • Two-factor codes. Authenticator apps often do not move automatically. Set this up before you switch phones. I wrote about it in transferring two-factor codes to a new phone.
  • Messaging history. WhatsApp, for example, has its own backup setting. Check it separately.
  • Passwords. Keep them in a password manager so they are not trapped in one device.
  • App data. Some apps store nothing in your backup.
  • Files in app folders. They may not be copied at all.

The 3-2-1 idea

A well-known rule from the IT world: keep three copies of important data, on two different kinds of storage, with one copy somewhere else. For a phone that could look like:

  1. The phone itself.
  2. A cloud backup (iCloud or Google).
  3. A periodic copy of photos and key files on a computer or external drive.

If you only have one, make it the cloud. If you can add a second, make it the computer.

For people with expensive data

Cloud backups upload a lot, and in places where data is expensive or Wi-Fi is slow, that is a real cost. Options:

  • Back up only when you are on stable Wi-Fi.
  • Choose what gets backed up. Switch off big apps you do not need.
  • Back up to a computer at home, where the cost is zero.
  • Compress or delete big videos before they hit your cloud storage.

How to test a backup

A backup you have never tested is a hope. Try these, in order of effort:

  1. Check the date of the last backup in settings. If it says last month, fix it.
  2. Look at what is included. Is photo storage on? Are your key apps ticked?
  3. Open your cloud photos on a computer or another device. If they show up, the system works.
  4. Do a trial restore onto a spare phone, if you have one, at least once.

Managing a site from your phone?

If your phone has your CMS login, shop app, and authenticator, a lost phone is a bigger deal than lost photos. Make sure those are recoverable: backup codes saved, a password manager, and a second way in. I’d treat the phone as a key, not a vault.

Common myths

“My photos are in the cloud, so I’m backed up.” Only if photo sync is on and finished. Check.

“iCloud and Google are the same.” They back up different things in different ways.

“A backup is for lost phones only.” It also saves you from a bad update, accidental deletion and a broken screen.

Key takeaways

  • Free cloud storage is small, so most people need a paid tier or a second method.
  • A computer backup costs nothing but depends on your habit.
  • Check what is not backed up, especially authenticator apps and chats.
  • Use more than one method for what matters.
  • Test your backup before you need it.

When did your phone last finish a backup? Look at the date in your settings now.