Blog / Digital growth /

Rankings aren’t revenue: setting SEO goals a business cares about

“We want to be number one on Google.”

It’s the goal I hear most often, and I understand why. It’s simple, it’s visible, and you can check it yourself by searching. But ask the follow-up (“number one for what, and what happens when you are?”) and the answer often goes quiet.

SEO serves the business. Rankings and traffic are useful signs along the way, but they aren’t the point. A goal that stops at “rank higher” can be hit while the business gets nothing from it. It’s easy to produce an SEO report full of green arrows and no answer to the only question the owner cares about: is this bringing in customers?

Why rankings make a weak goal on their own

  • Rankings vary. Different people see different results depending on location, device and search history. “We’re number three” is often true only for you, today.
  • A ranking can have no value. First place for a keyword nobody searches, or one that brings the wrong visitors, is a trophy, not a result.
  • Search results have more in them now: ads, maps, videos, “People also ask”. Position one can sit a long way down the page.
  • It encourages the wrong work. Chasing a single big keyword can eat months that would have been better spent on ten smaller searches closer to a sale.

Why traffic isn’t much better

More visitors sounds good. But traffic is a means, not an end.

A blog post that brings 10,000 visits a month from people looking for a free definition may do nothing for a business that sells a service. A page that brings 200 visits from people comparing providers in their city might bring in most of the enquiries.

I went into the metrics that tend to mislead in measuring content performance without vanity metrics.

Start from the business goal

Good SEO goals come from asking what the business needs, then working backwards:

  1. What does the business need? More enquiries? More sales of a particular product? More students in the next intake? Fewer support calls?
  2. Which of those can search realistically help with? People search before they buy, enquire, enrol and complain.
  3. What would people search on the way? That’s where keyword research comes in.
  4. Which pages need to exist, rank and convert for that to happen?

Now the goal isn’t “rank for X”. It’s “get more of the right people to these pages, and have those pages do their job”.

A simple structure for SEO goals

I find it helps to set goals at three levels:

1. Business outcome (what the owner cares about)

  • enquiries or leads from organic search
  • sales or revenue from organic search
  • sign-ups, bookings or enrolments
  • calls or direction requests from a Google Business Profile

2. Search performance (what SEO directly influences)

  • clicks from search to the pages that matter
  • impressions and positions for a group of commercially useful searches, not one vanity keyword
  • click-through rate on key pages

3. Health and activity (what you control week to week)

  • important pages indexed and error-free
  • pages updated or published on schedule
  • technical fixes completed

Report all three, but judge success on the first. The second explains it. The third shows the work is happening.

Make it measurable

None of this works if you can’t measure the outcome. That means:

  • Conversions set up in analytics. With GA4 now the only Google Analytics, mark the events that matter (form submissions, purchases, sign-ups) as conversions. See GA4 events for beginners.
  • Organic search separated from other channels in reports.
  • A baseline. Write down where things are before you start, so you know if anything changes.
  • A sensible timeframe. SEO usually takes months. Quarterly goals are more realistic than weekly ones.

Some value is hard to track directly, like someone who reads three posts, leaves, and calls a week later. That’s fine. Note it, and don’t let it become an excuse to measure nothing.

Be honest about what SEO can’t do

SEO can bring the right people to a page. It can’t fix a weak offer, a confusing checkout, slow replies to enquiries or a price that’s out of line with the market. If organic traffic to a product page is rising and sales aren’t, the problem might not be search at all.

That’s also why I’m wary of any SEO promise with a guaranteed position or number attached. Nobody controls Google’s results. What you can promise is the work, the measurement and honest reporting.

What’s your current SEO goal? Try finishing this sentence: “If this works, the business will get more ___.” If you can’t fill the blank, that’s the goal to rewrite first.