Blog / Tech, New & Old /
Tech I thought would fail but did not
Predicting which technology will fail is a great way to look silly later. I’ve done it more than once. This isn’t a list of confessions about specific products I bought and regretted, because I’d rather not invent a story. It’s about the pattern: the kinds of tech that look doomed at first and survive anyway, and what that says about how to judge anything new.
Why “this will fail” is such an easy call
When something new arrives, its flaws are obvious and its future isn’t. The first version is slow, expensive, awkward or missing the one feature you want. It’s easy to point at that and say “nobody needs this”.
The trouble is that early versions aren’t the real product. They are the beginning of a process, and the people who bet against technology often judge the starting line as if it were the finish.
The patterns that fool us
1. The “it’s a toy” trap. Many lasting technologies started as hobbyist gadgets. Smartphones were once seen as business toys for people with too much money. Early websites were seen as brochures. Judged by what they did on day one, they looked trivial. Judged by what they enabled, they weren’t.
2. The “we already have something” trap. Why would anyone need a phone camera when they have a camera? Why a tablet when there’s a laptop? The answer is usually convenience. The thing in your pocket beats the better thing at home. The best camera is, famously, the one you have with you. If you want to see how this plays out today, phone cameras vs real cameras for a small business is the same argument in a modern setting.
3. The “nobody will pay for that” trap. Free sounds like a solid habit, so paying for music, video or software sounded unlikely. Then streaming and subscriptions became normal. Not everyone loves it; I’ve written about the downside in subscriptions hidden inside your gadgets. But “people won’t pay” was wrong.
4. The “too complicated” trap. Technology often looks too hard until someone wraps it in a simple interface. Online banking, mobile money and video calls all looked like things only careful people would try. Then they became ordinary. Mobile money in Africa is a good example; I touched on it in M-Pesa and how Africa leapfrogged banks.
5. The “look at those flaws” trap. Short battery life, slow connection, poor screens. All of these improve. Judging a product by a flaw that time will fix is a classic mistake.
Tech that people wrote off, then relied on
A few categories that were doubted at some stage and are now normal:
- Touchscreen phones. Plenty of people liked physical keyboards and insisted typing on glass would never work. Most of us now type on glass daily. I looked back at the phones I grew up with in from the Nokia 3310 to smartphones.
- Wireless earbuds. Easy to lose, needing charging, worse sound than wired in the early days. Now everywhere, though wired headphones are not dead either.
- Smartwatches. Doubted as a gadget for nobody. Now many people wear one, even if the best use is narrower than the marketing suggested. Smartwatches for people who hate notifications goes into that.
- Online shopping. Many people said they would always want to see and touch things first. A huge number of businesses now depend on it. If you run an online shop, you’re living in that prediction going wrong.
Tech I’m right to be cautious about (and why that’s different)
None of this means every new thing succeeds. Plenty fail: Windows Phone, Flash, many gadgets that aged badly. I covered that in mobile operating systems that failed and Flash Player is gone.
The difference is usually not the flaws, which every new product has. It’s whether the thing solves a real problem for real people better than the alternative, and whether the ecosystem around it (developers, accessories, networks) joins in. Windows Phone had a decent product but lacked apps. That’s a failure of ecosystem, not of idea.
A better test than “will it fail?”
Instead of predicting, ask three questions:
- What problem does this solve? Be specific. “It’s cool” isn’t a problem.
- Is it cheaper, faster or easier than what people do now? Even at one of those, it can win.
- Who else needs to join in for it to work? Developers, retailers, networks, standards. If nobody comes, great tech can die.
And add a fourth for yourself: do I have to decide now? Most of the time you don’t. You can wait and watch. That’s why I argue against rushing to buy on launch day in why I would never buy a phone on launch day.
What running websites taught me
On the web you hear confident claims like “nobody will ever read long posts”, “nobody will ever buy on a phone” and “nobody will use that platform”. Some of it was right for a while and wrong later. I now treat strong “never” statements with suspicion, my own included. Check the behaviour of real people instead of the confident opinion of an expert.
Key takeaways
- Early versions of technology are not the finished product.
- Convenience beats quality more often than people expect.
- Flaws that time can fix are poor reasons to dismiss something.
- Ecosystem and usefulness decide survival more than specs.
- Be modest about predictions, including your own.
Related reading
Which tech did you dismiss that ended up in your daily life?