Blog / Tech, New & Old /

Why tech companies copy each other

Open any two big apps and you’ll find the same things in both. Stories at the top. A short-video feed. A tab for messages. A new button for AI. When one company launches something that catches on, the others have a version within months.

Copying looks lazy, and sometimes it is. My argument is that most of the time it’s a rational response to how technology markets work. It’s only a problem when the copy is all the company has.

It’s an old habit

The graphical interface on your computer is a good example. Xerox’s research centre, PARC, developed ideas like windows, icons and the mouse-driven desktop in the 1970s. Apple built on those ideas for the Lisa and Macintosh, and Microsoft brought its own version to Windows. Nobody thinks of the modern computer as stolen; it’s a long chain of people taking a good idea and improving on it.

More recently, Instagram added Stories in 2016, after Snapchat had popularised the format. Later, Reels and YouTube Shorts followed the short-video model that TikTok took global. In 2023, Meta launched Threads, a text-based app that looked a lot like Twitter, and many of those features appeared elsewhere afterwards.

Reason one: users set the expectation

Once people get used to something, they expect it everywhere. If one phone lets you pay by tapping, or one messaging app lets you edit a message after sending, the others look broken without it. Copying here is about not losing customers.

Reason two: it’s cheaper to follow than to guess

Launching a new idea means betting money and months of work on something that might flop. Waiting to see which ideas succeed turns an uncertain bet into a clearer one. “Fast follower” is a legitimate strategy: let someone else do the expensive learning, then do it better or at larger scale.

Reason three: platforms need to defend themselves

If a rival’s feature keeps people on their app longer, your app loses attention. For companies that earn money from time and attention, matching a feature isn’t vanity but defence. A big company can add a copy to an existing user base overnight, which is why small startups sometimes find a feature they pioneered built into a giant’s product.

Reason four: the same talent and the same tools

People move between companies, and the same engineers and designers carry ideas with them. Companies also rely on similar technology: the same cloud providers, the same frameworks, the same AI models. When everyone has the same building blocks, similar things come out.

Reason five: standards help everyone

Some copying is deliberate and good. USB-C on phones and laptops, passkeys, the Qi standard for wireless charging all exist because companies agreed on a shared approach. Convergence means your charger works with more devices. Regulation sometimes pushes it, such as the European Union’s rules on common chargers, which I covered in USB-C on iPhone.

When copying becomes a problem

  • When the copy is the strategy. If a product has no reason to exist except to match another, it has nothing to protect it when the rival improves.
  • When it makes everything the same. If every app adopts the same layout and features, users lose choice. A scroll of near-identical video feeds is worth worrying about.
  • When it crushes the originator. A big company absorbing a small company’s idea can kill the smaller one, which discourages new ideas.
  • When it breaks the law. Copying ideas is legal in most cases. Copying code, designs or branding that are protected is not. Patent and copyright disputes between tech firms happen often, and the line between inspiration and infringement is for courts.

The strongest counter-argument

“If everyone copies, nobody innovates, and the whole industry stagnates.”

It’s a reasonable worry, but history is more mixed. Copying spreads good ideas fast and raises the baseline for users. The real innovation often comes after copying, when a company takes a familiar idea and finds a better way to do it. The first MP3 players, for instance, existed years before the iPod; what Apple added was software and design that made the whole thing easy. Copying gets you to parity. It doesn’t get you ahead.

What this means for web builders

If you run a site or a small business, there’s a quiet lesson. Copying competitors is tempting: matching their features, pages and prices. But copying the surface gets you only the surface.

Better questions are:

  • Why did that feature work for them? Their customers and their goals may differ from yours.
  • What can I do for my audience that a bigger company can’t? Specialist knowledge, local detail and a personal voice are hard to copy.
  • Is this a trend or a standard? Some features become required. Others fade.

I wrote something similar about SEO: matching what competitors publish rarely wins unless you add something they don’t. It’s the same idea in a different industry.

How to read the next “revolution”

When you see a flashy launch, ask three things:

  1. Is this really new, or a polished version of something that exists?
  2. Who did it first, and what happened to them?
  3. What does this company bring to it that a copy wouldn’t?

The honest answers tell you whether it’s a real step forward or a defensive move.

Key takeaways

  • Copying is old, common and often rational: users expect features, and following is cheaper than guessing.
  • Standards and shared building blocks produce useful similarity.
  • Copying becomes a problem when it is the only strategy or when it flattens choice.
  • Copying gets you parity; real advantage comes from what you add.

Which app feature do you wish everyone else would copy, and which one do you wish they’d stop?