Blog / Shopify & e-commerce /

A practical framework for deciding which products deserve SEO work

Every store has a product with a juicy keyword and a page nobody can fulfil. And every store has a quiet product that would sell nicely with a bit of attention. The spreadsheet can’t tell them apart.

A product deserves SEO work when there’s a credible opportunity and the business can support the page, not just because a keyword has high volume. Prioritisation should connect demand, relevance, availability, margin context where you’re authorised to use it, and the quality of the current experience. Confidential commercial information stays inside approved systems. A transparent framework lets a team explain why one product gets attention and another waits.

Establish eligibility first

Check that the product is active, accurate, available (or has a clear availability explanation) and that its page can actually be improved. Confirm the source data and whether the item has real differentiation.

Don’t promote a product that can’t be fulfilled or whose claims are unclear. Find out which commercial inputs you may use and who is allowed to see them.

Score opportunity and readiness

Consider search intent, existing visibility, competition, page quality, internal links, stock stability and business priority. Use a simple rubric, and don’t pretend to calculate a precise universal score.

Keep opportunity and readiness apart. A promising query may still need better product data or imagery before SEO work makes sense. I write down my assumptions and my confidence next to each score, so someone can challenge the order of the tasks.

Review the portfolio

Pick a manageable group, agree the specific improvement and decide what you’ll check later. If you need to learn what helped, don’t change titles, copy, links and merchandising all at once.

Revisit the priorities when stock or strategy changes. In my work at Garey I’d rather run a small, clear batch than a wide one I can’t read afterwards.

Keep the work reviewable

Start the next prioritisation round with one question the current system can answer, such as which active products have no description at all. A narrow scope is one a person can validate.

State the date, source and conditions of each figure you use. A keyword volume or a stock level without a date can be mistaken for a lasting fact.

Compare one ordinary product with one exception, like an item with a missing value or an outdated URL, and see whether the behaviour differs for a reason the owner can explain.

Know which system is authoritative for stock and price, and which merely displays it. A copied field shouldn’t override the real source.

If search data and sales data disagree, don’t merge them. Check definitions, timing and scope with the owners and leave the difference visible until it is explained.

Keep confirmed facts, likely explanations and proposed actions apart in the notes. They sit side by side but don’t weigh the same.

Before you apply a rule to the whole catalogue, test it on one representative product and check the live page after publication.

Name the person who can answer a product, language or measurement question. A broad team isn’t a contact.

When the evidence is incomplete, say what’s missing and choose a next check that reduces the uncertainty. Don’t fill the gap with a neat guess.

Record each change with a short reason and an owner, and keep the earlier state for comparison.

After the change, revisit the same product and confirm that the buyer’s task still works.

A useful handover names the person who can answer a domain, product, language or measurement question, depending on the topic. Pointing at a broad team leaves the next editor with nobody to ask when a number looks odd.

Keep the maintenance note short but specific: the owner, the source and the event that should trigger another review, such as a range change or a supplier update. A real event is a better prompt than a recurring calendar reminder.

When you present the ranking, state its limitation in the same place as the recommendation. A manager reading it should see what is known, what remains uncertain and why the proposed next action is proportionate to the evidence.

Which product has both a clear customer need and enough evidence to justify work now?