Blog / Digital growth /

Is SEO dead? Every year someone says so

“SEO is dead.” You’ve seen the headline. You’ll see it again next year, and the year after that. It comes round whenever search changes, traffic dips or someone finds a shiny new platform.

It makes a good headline and a poor diagnosis. Search behaviour changes, search engines change, and tactics go stale. Helping people find useful pages still matters. So the better question isn’t “is SEO alive?” It’s whether organic search still fits your audience and business, and whether you’re adapting to how people find and choose information.

Why the claim keeps returning

SEO depends on a channel businesses don’t control. A search engine changes its results, a platform sends less traffic, a technical change costs visibility. It feels like the whole discipline has failed.

But SEO isn’t one trick or one position. It’s making pages accessible, explaining a product clearly, understanding intent, building useful information and measuring what happens. Old tactics stop working. The need to be found doesn’t.

The claim also spreads because “SEO is dead” is more dramatic than “this specific tactic works less well”. It sells services and gets attention. I always ask what exactly is supposedly dead: keyword research, links, content, technical work or search as a channel? Those are different claims.

Search is changing, not disappearing

People find answers and products through search engines, marketplaces, social platforms, video, forums and AI assistants. The mix depends on the audience and the task. Someone comparing a household product may browse a marketplace. Someone diagnosing a technical problem may search and then read a forum.

So learn where your audience actually looks. Don’t abandon search because a new interface appeared. Search still connects a question to a page, and plenty of journeys use more than one channel.

Google’s March 2024 core update is still underway as I write, and AI features are getting a lot of attention. Neither proves SEO work has ended. The rollout may shift visibility, but conclusions need data and time.

What is worth continuing

Technical accessibility still pays off. If a page can’t be crawled, loads badly or has a confusing URL, both a search engine and a person will struggle. Clear navigation and internal links help visitors find what matters.

Content still needs a purpose: answer a real question, support a buying decision or offer information the business can stand behind. Volume alone isn’t a strategy. Update old pages when there’s a reason, and merge or remove what no longer serves a reader.

Measurement still matters. Rankings are one signal. Look at clicks, qualified visits, leads and sales. If organic traffic falls, find out which pages and queries are affected before you declare a whole channel dead.

When SEO may not be your priority

SEO doesn’t suit every goal or timeline. If you need demand for an event next week, paid promotion, partners or direct outreach will probably do better. If your audience doesn’t use web search to find your offer, another channel makes more sense.

Even then, a clear, findable website helps people who hear about you elsewhere. I’d rather you prioritise by customer behaviour than treat SEO as either compulsory or obsolete.

A useful way to respond to change

When a platform changes, ask:

  1. What exactly changed, and what is confirmed?
  2. Which pages or audiences could be affected?
  3. What does Search Console or analytics show over a meaningful period?
  4. Is the issue technical, content-related, competitive or seasonal?
  5. What small test would reduce uncertainty?

Don’t rewrite the whole site because a social post predicted the end of search. Equally, don’t ignore evidence because an old tactic used to work. Fit the work to the actual problem.

Keep the channel decision commercial

A useful channel review compares the cost, timing and likely audience of each option. Organic search takes time and ongoing work. Paid promotion brings visits quickly and stops when the spending stops. Email, partnerships, marketplaces or direct sales may suit a specific offer better. The right mix changes as the business grows.

Don’t defend SEO because you’ve already invested in it, and don’t drop it because a competitor announced a new tactic. Set a clear question, look at the evidence and adjust. If search brings the wrong visitors, fix the targeting and the landing page. If it isn’t a priority, put resources elsewhere and keep the essential site information clear.

FAQ

Is SEO still worth doing in 2024?

It can be, when your audience uses search and the work connects to business goals. Prioritise it against other channels and measure meaningful outcomes.

Will AI replace search engines?

Search interfaces are evolving, but there is no basis to assume every user or task will move to one system. Follow how your audience behaves.

What should I do after a traffic drop?

Check the affected pages, queries, technical status and timing. Compare with known updates and other changes, then diagnose before acting.

Take one recent “SEO is dead” claim and ask what evidence it actually offers. Then compare it with how your own customers search. Which one do you believe?