Blog / Shopify & e-commerce /

January sales pages: reuse them or make new ones each year?

Search Console has a habit of showing you ghosts. Look at the Pages report for a store that’s been running a few years and you’ll often find /collections/january-sale-2021, /collections/january-sale-2022 and /collections/january-sale-2023, each with a handful of impressions, each now a 404 or a redirect to the homepage.

Three years of sale pages, and none of them built anything that lasted.

My answer to “reuse or make new?” is almost always reuse. Keep one permanent URL for the January sale, leave the year out of it, and update the page each year. Here’s why, how to handle the eleven months when there’s no sale, and the cases where a fresh page is the right call.

Why one URL wins

A sale page picks up links over its life: a deal site mentions it, a local blog lists it, your own newsletter and social posts point at it. Some of those links stay live for years.

If the page moves to a new URL every January, last year’s links point at a dead page or a redirect. If the URL stays the same, every year’s links add to the same page. After a few seasons, that page has a head start over anything you could create in a week.

Google already knows the page

A URL that’s existed for years, gets crawled regularly and has a history of being relevant for “january sale [your niche]” searches has an easier time ranking quickly in January than a brand new URL Google first sees on 2 January. New pages can take days or weeks to be crawled, indexed and settle. In a sale that lasts three or four weeks, that delay costs you most of the season.

Less to clean up

Every new sale URL is another page that needs redirecting, another entry in the sitemap, another possible 404 in the indexing report. One permanent page means one thing to maintain.

How to set it up on Shopify

  1. Create a collection with a timeless handle: /collections/january-sale or simply /collections/sale, not /collections/january-sale-2024. Shopify lets you edit the handle; do it before the URL starts collecting links. I covered what Shopify does and doesn’t let you change in Shopify URL structure: what you can and can’t change.
  2. Put the year in the content, not the URL. The title tag and H1 can say “January Sale 2024”. Next year, you update the text. The URL stays put.
  3. Make it a smart (automated) collection where it fits, with a condition such as a “sale” tag or “compare-at price is greater than price”, so products drop in and out as discounts change.
  4. Link to it from somewhere permanent, such as the footer or a “Sale” menu item, at least during the season.

What to do when the sale ends

This is where most stores go wrong. The sale finishes, the page gets deleted or hidden, and the URL starts returning a 404. Then next January it has to start again.

Better options, roughly in order of preference:

Keep it live with an honest message

Leave the page published with a short message at the top: “Our January sale has finished. It’s back every January. Sign up to hear when it starts.” Below that, show your current offers or a few bestsellers so the visit isn’t wasted.

Someone searching “january sale” in March is unusual, but someone arriving from an old link isn’t. Give them something useful.

Turn it into an all-year sale page

If you always have some discounted products, rename the page in its quiet months (“Sale”) and keep it stocked through the automated collection. In January, change the title and banner to “January Sale”. Same URL, different season.

Hide it from the menu, but don’t delete it

If you really don’t want the page visible, take it out of the navigation and leave the URL working. Don’t noindex it on a whim; that sends Google mixed signals each year when you switch it back on.

What I’d avoid is redirecting the sale page to the homepage after every season. It’s a common habit, and Google tends to treat redirects to irrelevant pages like soft 404s anyway.

When a new page does make sense

Reuse isn’t a rule for everything:

  • A one-off event. A closing-down sale, a warehouse clear-out or an anniversary sale that won’t repeat can have its own page, and should be redirected to the closest relevant collection when it’s over.
  • A genuinely different offer. If January is “sale” and February is “new season launch”, those are different pages with different jobs. Don’t cram both into one URL.
  • A brand-new store. No history to protect, but the same advice applies from day one: make the first sale page the permanent one.
  • Old year-stamped pages already exist. Pick the strongest one (most links, most impressions), change its handle if needed, and 301-redirect the others to it. Shopify adds a redirect automatically when you change a handle, if you tick the box.

Getting the January content right

A reused URL still needs fresh, accurate content each year:

  • Update the dates and the year in the title, H1 and any banner text. Nothing says “nobody looks after this site” like “January Sale 2022” in 2024.
  • Write a short intro about what’s actually discounted and for how long. A collection page with only product cards is a thin page; category descriptions that actually help shoppers covers what to write.
  • Check that discounts show correctly in the product structured data, so the prices in search results match the page.
  • Plan it before Christmas, not on 1 January. Seasonal keywords: planning e-commerce content for Q4 has the timing approach, and January follows the same logic.

FAQ

Should the year be in the title tag?

During the sale, yes, if people search with it. “January sale 2024” is a common way of phrasing it. Just update it every year, and drop the year from the title when the sale isn’t running.

Is it bad to have a sale page with no products on sale?

An empty collection with no explanation is a poor page. One with a clear “back in January” message and current offers is fine. Make the off-season version useful rather than empty.

Search your Shopify admin for every collection with a year in its handle. How many old sale pages could be folding their links into one permanent page?