Blog / Tech, New & Old /
What BlackBerry can teach today’s tech companies
BlackBerry didn’t lose because it built a bad phone. That’s what makes the story worth telling.
For years the company made the phone that serious people carried. The keyboard was brilliant, the email was fast, and the messaging service was something people got a little addicted to. Then the iPhone arrived in 2007, apps took over, and BlackBerry spent the next decade trying to find its footing. If you want the fond version, I’ve written about the BlackBerry keyboard and why people loved it and about BlackBerry Messenger.
This post is the harder version: what a company that big, with fans that loyal, actually got wrong, and what today’s tech companies can learn from it.
Lesson one: your best customers can mislead you
BlackBerry’s core audience was business users and, in time, a large crowd of ordinary people who loved typing on a real keyboard. They were happy. They said so. The easy conclusion is “keep giving them what they like.”
The trouble is that happy existing customers tell you about today’s needs, not tomorrow’s. People who love a keyboard will tell you to improve the keyboard. They won’t tell you they want an app store, because they haven’t imagined one yet.
The takeaway: listen to your customers, but watch what people who aren’t your customers yet are doing. That’s where the next shift shows up first.
Lesson two: a phone became a platform
BlackBerry sold a device with great email. Apple (and soon Google with Android) sold a pocket computer that other people could build for. Once developers could make apps, each new app made the platform more useful, which brought more users, which brought more developers.
That loop is hard to beat from outside. BlackBerry later launched its own new operating system, BlackBerry 10, in 2013, but by then the developers and the users were elsewhere. Apps people wanted on other platforms often simply never arrived on BlackBerry.
For anyone running a product or a website: a thing that feels complete today can be a feature of someone else’s platform tomorrow. Ask which ecosystem your users actually live in.
Lesson three: strengths become habits
Security, battery life, physical keys and efficient data use were genuine strengths. They’d been the reason the company won. But a strength you’re proud of can slow down your reaction to a world that stopped valuing it quite so highly.
When touchscreens were new, a screen without keys felt like a step backwards to many keyboard fans. They weren’t being foolish. They were judging the new thing by the old rules.
It’s a very human mistake, and the fix isn’t to chase every trend. It’s to ask regularly: “If we were starting today, would we build this the same way?”
Lesson four: it’s not always about the product
BlackBerry’s problems weren’t just design. Pace mattered. Competitors shipped updates quickly and learned from the market. A company that is used to long product cycles can look slow next to teams that release constantly.
Software changed the rhythm. The phone stopped being a finished object and became something that improved after you bought it.
Lesson five: a loved feature is not a moat
The keyboard was loved so much that it became the brand. But a feature, however well made, can be copied or made irrelevant. Messaging is a good example. BlackBerry Messenger was sticky because everyone you knew was on it. Once cross-platform apps such as WhatsApp did the same job on any phone, the reason to stay on a particular handset got weaker.
The lesson for a product team is to ask what keeps people with you if a rival copies your best feature tomorrow. Network effects, data, habits and trust last longer than a single clever design.
What BlackBerry got right
It’s too easy to turn this into a joke. BlackBerry cared about security, and it built a messaging habit that millions loved. Some of its ideas came back in other forms: push email, encrypted messaging, and now a revival of interest in physical keys among a small group of fans. The company itself later shifted towards software and security services rather than making phones.
So it wasn’t a failure of intelligence. It was a failure to move when the ground shifted.
What today’s tech companies can take from it
You’ll notice this isn’t only about phones. Replace “BlackBerry” with any big name in a changing market and the questions look the same.
- Who are your future customers, not just current ones?
- Are you building a product or a platform? Platforms attract others to build for you.
- What would you do if your strongest feature stopped mattering?
- How fast can you ship, learn and change?
AI is the obvious example right now. Companies are rushing to bolt it onto everything. The BlackBerry lesson isn’t “add AI to every product”. It’s closer to: figure out what your users will do differently once the technology is normal, and be ready before they ask.
A practical test
If you build or run anything people depend on, try three questions once a quarter. What do our happiest customers never ask for? What are people who left us using instead? And what part of our product would we cut if a competitor offered it free? None of the answers is comfortable, which is exactly why they’re useful.
The fair counter-argument
Someone will say: “BlackBerry was doomed once the iPhone launched, whatever it did.” Maybe. Apple had huge advantages, and the shift to touch and apps was powerful. But companies in tough positions still choose how fast they respond. Nokia and BlackBerry both had years of warning, and both had very large customer bases to lean on. The question isn’t whether disruption could be avoided entirely; it’s whether the response could have come earlier.
Related reading
Which product or tool do you love so much that you’d forgive it for being slow to change? And is that loyalty helping you, or just keeping you comfortable?