E-commerce SEO KPIs worth tracking every month
A store owner gets their monthly SEO report. It says rankings are up for 40 keywords, the site has a health score of 92, and organic traffic rose 8%.
Their question is simple: “So did we sell more?”
If the report can’t answer that, it’s measuring the wrong things. SEO for an online store exists to bring in people who buy. Rankings, traffic and scores are useful on the way there, but they’re not the destination. I made the broader case in rankings aren’t revenue.
Here are the KPIs I think are worth checking every month, in the order I’d look at them.
The core five
1. Organic revenue
The number that matters most. In GA4, open Reports → Acquisition → Traffic acquisition, make sure the primary dimension is Session default channel group, and look at revenue for Organic Search.
It needs e-commerce tracking set up properly. If purchases aren’t coming through, fix that first. GA4 e-commerce tracking: the basics explains how. On Shopify, also compare with Shopify’s own sales reports. They won’t match exactly (they measure differently), but they should move in the same direction.
Compare it with the same month last year, not just last month. E-commerce is seasonal. November always beats October for most stores, and that’s not SEO.
2. Organic conversion rate
Purchases from organic sessions divided by organic sessions. If traffic rises but conversion rate falls, you may be ranking for searches that don’t lead to buying. If traffic is flat but conversion rate rises, you’re attracting better visitors, which is often the better result.
3. Non-brand clicks from Search Console
People searching for your brand name would probably find you anyway. Growth in non-brand searches is where SEO earns its keep.
In Search Console’s Performance report, add a query filter, choose Custom (regex), select “Doesn’t match regex”, and enter your brand name and its common misspellings, separated by |. For example: ekomshoes|ekom shoes|ekom. That shows clicks from everything except brand searches.
Track this number monthly. It’s the cleanest measure of whether your SEO is reaching new people. How to read the Search Console Performance report covers the filters.
4. Clicks to collection and product pages
Not all organic traffic is equal for a store. A blog post that brings 5,000 visits who never look at a product is less valuable than a collection page with 500 visits who buy.
In Search Console, filter pages by URL: containing /collections/ and containing /products/ (on Shopify), or your category and product paths on other platforms. Track clicks for each group monthly. These are your money pages.
5. Revenue by organic landing page
In GA4, the Landing page report (under Engagement) filtered to organic traffic shows which pages start sessions that end in sales. Add revenue as a metric if it isn’t there.
This is the most useful report for deciding what to work on next. Pages that bring sales deserve protecting and improving. Pages with lots of visits and no sales deserve a closer look.
Health checks (monthly, quick)
These don’t measure growth. They catch problems early.
Indexed product and collection pages
Search Console’s Page indexing report. If the number of indexed pages drops suddenly, or important products appear under “Crawled – currently not indexed” or “Discovered – currently not indexed”, something needs looking at. The page indexing report explained goes through each status.
Core Web Vitals
The Core Web Vitals report in Search Console groups URLs as good, needing improvement or poor for LCP, FID and CLS. Check it monthly for sudden changes, usually caused by a new app or theme change. Keep an eye on INP too, since it replaces FID in March 2024.
Product structured data
Search Console’s Merchant listings and Product snippets reports flag missing prices, availability or review data. A theme update can break these without anyone noticing.
Useful, with caveats
Average position
Average position is an average across every query and every impression. It can drop when you start ranking for more keywords (because the new ones start lower). I only look at it for specific, important queries, never for the site as a whole.
Impressions
Rising impressions with flat clicks can mean you’re appearing for more searches but not attractively enough, so check titles and meta descriptions. Or it can mean you’ve started ranking on page two for lots of new terms, which is an early sign of growth. Useful context, not a goal.
Click-through rate
Worth checking for your top pages. A page in position 3 with a much lower CTR than its neighbours may need a better title. Title tags that get clicks without overpromising has the approach.
What I wouldn’t put in a monthly report
- Total keyword count from a third-party tool. It goes up and down with the tool’s own database.
- Domain authority or similar scores. They’re a tool’s estimate, not something Google uses.
- Site health scores. Useful for finding issues, meaningless as a goal.
- Bounce rate. In GA4, the more useful version is engagement rate, and even that matters less than whether people bought.
A simple monthly sheet
You don’t need a dashboard tool. One row per month, these columns:
| Month | Organic revenue | YoY change | Organic conv. rate | Non-brand clicks | Collection clicks | Product clicks | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
The Notes column is the most important one. Write what changed that month: a new theme, a sale, a Google update, a batch of new collection descriptions. In six months, it’s the only way to explain the numbers.
How I report SEO results to clients covers how I turn this into something people actually read.
Related reading
- Rankings aren’t revenue: setting SEO goals a business cares about
- GA4 e-commerce tracking: the basics
- Measuring content performance without vanity metrics
- How I report SEO results to clients
Set up the non-brand regex filter in Search Console today. It takes a minute, and it might change how you see your organic traffic.